Background and Context
On February 21, 2025, New York Governor Kathy Hochul met with President Donald Trump in the Oval Office. The meeting, lasting over an hour, covered congestion pricing, immigration, infrastructure, and economic development. Despite the high stakes, Hochul failed to secure any meaningful commitments, further exposing her weak leadership and lack of influence on the national stage.
Hochul, a Democrat, has long clashed with Trump, often using political theatrics to attack his administration. However, when it came to actual negotiation, she appeared ineffective. The federal government recently revoked approval for the city’s congestion pricing plan, prompting a lawsuit from the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA). The program, launched on January 5, 2025, charges vehicles a $9 toll to enter Manhattan south of 60th Street during peak hours. Hochul’s administration claims that the program has improved traffic flow and air quality, but Trump’s administration rightly opposed it, citing its burden on working-class New Yorkers.
The meeting also followed a Department of Justice lawsuit against New York over its sanctuary city policies. Hochul had previously postponed an earlier scheduled meeting with Trump, likely in an attempt to avoid direct confrontation. However, her presence in Washington, D.C., for the National Governors Association White House meeting forced her into an engagement she could no longer avoid.
Meeting Highlights
Hochul’s spokesman, Avi Small, confirmed the meeting and its focus on several key topics:
- Congestion Pricing: Hochul presented Trump with a 22-page document attempting to justify the congestion pricing program. Trump, however, remained unconvinced and pointed out its harmful impact on working-class residents.
- Immigration: The discussion touched on New York’s Green Light Law, which allows undocumented immigrants to obtain driver’s licenses and restricts federal access to DMV records. Trump’s administration strongly opposed this reckless policy.
- Infrastructure: The conversation included major projects such as the Second Avenue Subway expansion and Penn Station revitalization. Hochul failed to secure any definitive federal support.
- Economic Development and Energy: Hochul pushed for offshore wind and nuclear power, but her administration’s failing economic policies leave little room for confidence in her ability to implement them effectively.
Hochul’s office described the meeting as “frank” and “candid,” a standard political phrase used to mask her inability to achieve any real results. Trump, in an interview with the New York Post, called it “cordial” but dismissed her arguments, reinforcing the perception of her weak negotiating skills.
Implications and Next Steps
The meeting produced no tangible outcomes. Trump maintained his opposition to congestion pricing, and the legal battle over federal approval continues. Hochul reaffirmed her commitment to the toll program, but her defiant rhetoric does little to address its economic downsides.
Hochul’s willingness to meet with Trump, despite past attacks, exposes her desperation. Her administration relies heavily on federal support, yet she continues to alienate Washington decision-makers with her combative and ineffective leadership. The MTA’s lawsuit remains unresolved, and Hochul’s failure to secure federal backing only worsens the situation for New York commuters.
Public Reactions and Political Impact
Social media users quickly reacted to the meeting, with many criticizing Hochul’s lack of substance. Some noted her predictable talking points, while others pointed out her history of grandstanding without results. Even her political allies seemed underwhelmed by the lack of progress.
Economically, congestion pricing remains a controversial issue. The program faces legal challenges, and Hochul’s inability to gain federal support puts its future in jeopardy. Politically, her weak leadership continues to be a liability. Instead of standing firm for New Yorkers, she appears more interested in partisan grandstanding, a strategy that leaves the state without meaningful progress.
—–
Hochul’s meeting with Trump highlighted her political ineffectiveness. While she postured for the cameras, Trump remained firm, leaving her with no clear victories. As congestion pricing faces legal hurdles and infrastructure funding remains uncertain, Hochul’s weak governance continues to cost New Yorkers. The legal battle over congestion pricing will continue, but with Hochul at the helm, New York’s prospects for federal cooperation look increasingly bleak.
34,227 hits
